top of page

                    O7J Podcast                 

A Voice of Hope ​

​

Episode transcript.

Host: Inbal Tzarfati Cohen.

Guest: Attorney Yael Vias Gvirsman, founder of October 7 Justice Without Borders.

 

This episode contains triggering content, including a segment on sexual violence (marked below).

​

[00:00] Introduction

​

Inbal: Thank you for joining me for another episode of A Voice of Hope. A Voice of Hope is a project dedicated to Shiri, Ariel and Kfir Bibas, of blessed memory.

​

Today my guest is attorney Yael Vias Gvirsman, founder of October 7 Justice Without Borders, justice for the victims of October 7.

​

In moments when words no longer seem enough, when memory alone is left orphaned, a story told again and again still finds no answer or understanding. For those who were harmed, for families who lost their loved ones, the question is not only how to remember, but also how to bring justice, real, global justice, before an entire world.

​

What happens when we take the horrific crimes of October 7 beyond Israel's borders into the international legal arena, to the places where evidence meets the law, where testimonies become case files, and where the voice of victims must be heard even by legal systems thousands of kilometers away?

​

Today we go behind the scenes of this struggle, into the story of October 7 Justice Without Borders, a project born of the understanding that the fight for justice cannot stop at one border.

We'll talk about representing victims and families in the international arena, the legal challenges created by the crimes of October 7, gathering evidence, the accountability of those who committed the crimes, and also the biggest question of all: can real justice be achieved even after nearly three years have passed since that morning?

​

And this time, beyond law and justice, I want to get to know the people behind the struggle, the personal price of refusing to give up, the moment pain becomes a mission, and the belief that justice may, in the end, cross borders.

​

This is an episode about victims who deserve to have their voices heard, and about people who chose to be that voice for them, about a struggle that won't end until there is an answer. Justice Without Borders. Attorney Yael Vias Gvirsman. This is her journey.

​

The A Voice of Hope podcast may contain triggering content and calls for compassionate listening. The information in this podcast is not professional advice and is not a substitute for treatment and/or tailored professional guidance. The stories presented reflect only the personal experience of the interviewees.

​

A Voice of Hope, let's begin.

​

[03:33] Meet Attorney Yael Vias Gvirsman

​

Inbal: Attorney Yael, welcome to A Voice of Hope. Today we're hosting you to focus on Justice Without Borders, October 7 Justice Without Borders. First of all, good morning, and thank you so much for joining us.

​

Yael: Good morning, Inbal, thank you so much for having me.

​

Inbal: First I want people to understand who I'm talking with. Tell us who you are, your background and previous experience, and what drive led you to global justice.

​

Yael: I'm attorney Yael Vias Gvirsman. I've been a lawyer for over 20 years, specializing in international criminal law. What that means is accountability for the crimes we call "never again" crimes: Nazi crimes, 80 years since the Nuremberg trials, and atrocity trials for atrocities committed in the former Yugoslavia, Rwanda, Ukraine, and other arenas of mass criminality. That was my work until I woke up, like all of us, on October 7, and brought this need for accountability home as well.

​

[05:00] The morning of October 7 and the first calls for help

​

Inbal: I'd like to rewind for a moment to the very beginning, because you just mentioned October 7, which is really why we're gathered here. Justice Without Borders is about bringing to justice the people who committed those terrible atrocities, whoever can be prosecuted under the law.

​

You wake up on the morning of October 7, a Saturday, after Simchat Torah, on the holiday, and like everyone in Israel you're watching and hearing what's happening in the country and in the world, exposed to all the information and all the uncertainty, the chaos, the anxiety flooding all of us. But you see things differently than any ordinary person watching those videos. You grasp something deeper because of your experience, knowledge and background. I'd love for you to paint me a specific picture of that morning, and tell me about the moment you realized that Israel's own legal system would struggle to respond immediately, and that an outside body needed to step in.

​

Yael: It's hard to go back to that morning. It's been almost three years. The world hasn't gone back to how it was before October 7. For me it's still an arena that's still happening.

​

Personally, I experienced that day like everyone else, with horror, anxiety, deep shock. My family is in Tel Aviv, and my sister and her family live on a kibbutz nine kilometers from the Gaza border, so I was in existential fear for her and her family's safety. We were more or less cut off for 48 hours, apart from a few messages, and finally, to my immense joy, they were safe. The terrorists didn't reach them, though they came quite close, and eventually soldiers took up positions in her kibbutz, so I was a bit calmer.

​

But my personal experience is one I think all citizens of Israel share: a deep shock to that basic, profound belief that we are safe, that our home is safe. People abroad always asked me, how can you live in Israel? I'd tell them it's the safest place in the world, much safer than a street in Paris or Berlin, because I know there are amazing citizens here, and if something is wrong, and a lot is wrong, someone will respond.

​

That's what hit me on October 7. When did I realize my involvement was needed? I'd say it took me a few hours. On October 8 the first volunteers reached out to me, those citizens who to this day are the ones you can count on, the citizens of Israel who saved not only the country, but also my personal faith in all that is good in all of this. Beyond surviving physically, we also need to survive spiritually, to survive in our values and our beliefs, the basic things. The citizens of Israel were definitely there, in all their shades and colors and beauty, and they said, we're here, hineni, here I am.

​

So many people said hineni. I'm not the only one, and I'm not exceptional in that, though I am exceptional in my ability, my background and previous experience: twenty years of experience and a huge network of international experts, truly crossing borders, Jews and non-Jews, who stood by my side from the very first hours. Part of the injury and the rupture was the world's response, but at least on my personal and professional side, people stood by me, wonderful people, people of truth who said, we've devoted our lives to global justice, of course we'll do it in this arena too. They're part of my work today.

​

But when did I really realize intervention was needed? As I said, on October 8 the first volunteers reached out. There were 3,000 missing in the first days and weeks, and volunteers asked for help on their behalf. On October 10 they reached out again, and then came a call that moved me to the depths of my soul.

​

Those volunteers were asking on behalf of the amazing people they were supporting, many of them evacuees from the kibbutzim, and families of the Nova missing who were still missing. They made a seemingly very simple request: would you agree to talk to them? No one was talking to them, not the army, not the police, not Knesset members, not the government, not ministers. They were evacuees whose homes had burned and whose kibbutz no longer existed, and families of the missing from Nova and from other parties too, Psyduck and Midburn. Their only contact was with investigative, law enforcement and security forces, who either evacuated them in their pajamas after more than a day, or took DNA from them to identify their loved ones, and the news, good or terrible, hadn't come yet. Would you agree to talk to them? That's it.

​

Inbal: You say "that's it" so simply, but you were called up and went out on a very difficult mission. Those people, in the first moments, and you too, not understanding what was happening, like all of us, even with a lot of background and understanding from your field, it still suddenly hits us right here at home, live. Suddenly you're facing people in distress, in constant worry and anxiety, and giving them some kind of answer and support, because in the end an emotional bond forms. It's not a simple mission at all, and first of all I take my hat off to you for not hesitating and showing up when called.

​

[12:20] Who is being held accountable?

​

Inbal: What I really want to understand, and we touched on it in our phone call: on October 7, ordinary civilians breached the fence. Yes, there were Hamas operatives, there was UNRWA, we know all the facts, but there were also ordinary civilians that no one knows who they are or who they belong to. Now we're going into international law, into justice. So who are you suing?

​

Yael: Let me just finish about the mission. It looks hard, and there are definitely challenges, but personally, not doing it would have been harder for me than doing it.

​

At first I didn't know exactly how to define my role. There were several options, whether advancing policy or opening an atrocity archive, as I did with my legal clinic at Reichman University for Ukraine, an atrocity archive in cooperation with civil society organizations. In the end I turned to what I realized no one else was doing, which is what I do today: direct legal representation of hundreds of victims, free of charge, advancing legal proceedings for criminal, corporate and civil accountability, and also before UN human rights mechanisms. Those matter because their findings are important in recognizing these atrocities so they won't vanish from human memory, and in building the evidentiary basis for the legal proceedings we lead.

​

That brings me to your question, Inbal: who are you suing? I'm asked that in almost every conversation. You said ordinary civilians broke through the fence. I want to say that nothing here was random, even if part of it was, let's say, spontaneous. It relied on a very sophisticated, pre-planned infrastructure, with several factions that knew how to operate together. We're talking about at least 8,000 armed terrorists who broke through about a hundred points in the fence, backed by a range of heavy weapons. Everything was planned in advance.

​

What is shared, or similar, is a widespread, systematic attack against a civilian population, knowingly directed against civilians. That, by the way, is the definition of a crime against humanity, as opposed to what we might call an ordinary crime, an ordinary murder or rape. I don't mean that rape or murder is ordinary or simple, but there is a difference between a single murder of one person and a mass crime.

​

What we see in common in every mass crime around the world, and certainly on October 7, is an entire apparatus, a whole machine of evil. It's well planned, well funded, trained over many months if not many years, and it rests on an ideological infrastructure that enables these atrocities. That infrastructure turns the person in front of the perpetrator into a subhuman to whom anything can be done. In this case it is based on jihadist ideology, taking Quranic verses and more, much like ISIS did, not only to permit certain shocking, inhuman acts against a person or a group the perpetrator sees as a subhuman, an infidel, but even to command these acts as a noble deed. Committing these inhuman atrocities is perceived as a noble deed, and that's a matter of education.

​

So there is a long-standing infrastructure that enables carrying out this "commandment," and also an orderly plan, because we see a pattern. In legal proceedings, before we say whom we'll sue, we map the pattern of the crime: what this machine is, who was involved, what the idea was, what the plan was, who took part in conceiving this plan, in carrying it out, and in providing the means to carry it out.

​

So when we say whom we're suing, in short: we sue those who committed it directly, most of whom are detained in Israel and will stand trial in Israel, or were killed in combat. But more than that, we go after the indirect perpetrators, those who sent the direct perpetrators. If we think of it as a game of chess, the soldiers are the little pawns, very easy to kill and just as easy to replace. What really matters is who stands behind them, who sent them, who conceived the idea.

​

Alongside the direct and indirect perpetrators, we also have the collaborators, whoever assists in any way, material or ideological, in committing the crimes and even in continuing them. October 7 isn't a one-day crime in which the crimes were committed and ended. There are, of course, the crimes committed against hostages and their families, which international law also has a framework for, called a continuing crime.

​

We sue those people. Many tell me, but wait, they're all dead in Gaza. So I answer, what, there's no one speaking for Hamas today, for Islamic Jihad, for four other armed Palestinian militias? There's no one speaking for them proudly, openly, sitting in Qatar, in Turkey and elsewhere? And even more, they sit in democracies, in France, the Schengen area, Germany, Australia, South America, and operate on behalf of those organizations. The law can expose those organizations, must expose them, and must bring them to account for their part in these acts. We're not saying each one is responsible for all the acts, but each for their part in an orderly, complete plan carried out knowingly and with malice.

​

Alongside that, we also go after entities that are not linked to terror groups, entirely legitimate entities. For example, huge media companies and major platforms around the world, and banks, which have compliance obligations so they don't finance terrorism or launder money. There is international legislation, and certainly in Israel too. Those banks and companies breached their duties, including in the European Union, and transferred funding directly to terror groups, turning them into some of the richest terror groups in the world. Hamas is the second richest terror organization in the world, worth billions.

​

Instead of building, let's say, a state, but at least an amazing piece of land for the welfare of the Palestinian people in Gaza, on roughly 360 square kilometers, they built underground a tunnel system among the most sophisticated in the world. In some places you can drive whole trucks through it, an entire city of some 500 kilometers beneath the ground. And they didn't bother to build even one shelter so that even one Gazan child would be protected. In doing so, Hamas and its partners, the other militias, also carried out a calculated attack against the population in Gaza too.

​

Inbal: As you say, these are all things we know, yet every time we hear it again, it hits home how horrifying the facts are. You framed the question very well, because many people do say that most of them are dead, but the bearers of the ideology, the people behind it, the people of power and influence, are still walking around the world. As you say, they're in Europe, in Qatar, living their lives, wonderful lives for that matter, lives of abundance, while the ordinary people of Gaza are captive to this ideology. And as you described it, those ordinary people become the ones who go into battle, the ones who breached the fence, disposable people in this whole terrible saga. People who can be sacrificed.

​

Yael: Yes. 2.3 million people, of whom 8,200 armed men breached the fence. And it's been 2.3 million people not just for three years, but for twenty years now, since the IDF left Gaza and Hamas was elected to power, and all political opposition was wiped out under a regime of terror lasting over twenty years, creating a population driven by hatred, without hope.

I'm sure that among those 2.3 million there are also amazing people who are afraid, just like us, and who want something different, but they have no platform today to give them hope or any change. Of course the individual matters, but what matters in fighting these phenomena is the system, and we see a system of twenty years, an orderly system for creating hatred, which is the foundation of what happened on October 7 and what, sadly, could still happen. We're not far from it.

​

You say, Inbal, that they're living around the world. But even more than that, Hamas still exists, not just as an ideology, which is one thing, but they are still armed. How can there still be a single weapon in Gaza that isn't on the Israeli side? They're still armed, and their spirit doesn't seem to have been broken by the fighting, which is truly sad and truly affects all of us. We must learn the lessons and understand the failures to prevent the next disaster, because sadly it's clear they won't stop, and they're already planning the next attack. We want arrest warrants at least, even against those in Qatar and so on. Whether or not they get arrested, we want international arrest warrants issued against them.

​

Inbal: I agree with you, at the very least. Of course, it's very important.

​

[23:30] The early days: the UN and the hostages

​

Inbal: Now, as we're talking, let me take you back to the beginning, when you were already getting to work. We had hostages in Gaza, so much uncertainty, so much fighting still going on, and Israel was in chaos, all of us trying to hold ourselves together. And you, and I say "you" because you truly had amazing volunteers we'll hear about later, were collecting testimonies and submitting harrowing reports to committees and institutions. At first, as we all know, there was a split second when some compassion was shown toward Israel, but it vanished very quickly. Can you share the responses you encountered? Was there any real attention to the hostages and the helpless victims at the UN and the human rights bodies where you presented the testimonies?

​

Yael: First, let me clarify: we don't write reports. We give direct assistance to the victims first, and then turn their case into legal action, meaning we bring legal tools. What we did first was to receive people, take them in, understand their needs and map them.

​

The need is very different when it's a crime already committed and over, like, sadly, the murder of a loved one, versus someone still fighting to save a loved one who is being held captive. This unimaginable combination created a horrific reality for a person who had just survived the worst of all, perhaps barely, evacuated from a home that no longer exists, from a community that exists in spirit but is physically uprooted, in pain, and burying its loved ones: grandmothers, grandfathers, children, women, men. The perpetrators were completely blind to any human reality, to any limits whatsoever, to the humanity of the other. There was no compassion there. That's the reality.

​

And then, out of those very ashes, these people had to rise, find the strength, and fight for the release of the hostages. First of all, just to find out whether their loved ones were alive or not. I represent women who, in the first days, I remember, made heartbreaking appeals to the cameras, hoping maybe someone would find their daughter or their mother, and days later it turned out that they had, sadly, been murdered already on October 7.

​

Part of the chaos of identifying who is alive and who is not is part of the plan, by the way. When you see the terrorists using a substance that can set anything on fire at 750 degrees, that's not an ordinary accelerant. It's not fuel you find at the supermarket or at a gas station. That chaos is part of the plan. So is bringing in journalists and spreading the atrocities in real time as much as possible, digitally, and creating as much suffering as possible. Digital terrorism, psychological terrorism, it's all part of the plan.

​

So what did we do in terms of UN mechanisms in the first days? We mapped all the relevant UN mechanisms, and you have to understand there are dozens, even hundreds of them: special rapporteurs and working groups, each with a different role and mandate, whether against prohibited acts like torture, sexual crimes and enforced disappearances, or protecting special populations like children, women, the elderly and people with disabilities. We approached each of these bodies to understand whether an appeal would increase the danger to whoever had been abducted, whether it would put lives at risk or not.

​

One example is our approach to the Working Group on Enforced Disappearances. We spoke with people who had worked there before and no longer do, so they could speak openly, and with people who worked there at that very time. We asked, okay, what can we do? They have general reports, so things get published and recorded in the human archive, and that matters. But right now we were talking about an emergency, because until the hostages were released we were still in an emergency, saving lives. The first rule in saving lives is do no harm. Our work must not, God forbid, cause harm or endanger lives.

​

They told us: you write a letter and an appeal on behalf of a specific person, you disclose their name, and that letter is sent to Hamas and the militias holding the people. I had to pinch myself to understand, wait, are you serious? I asked what the outcomes have been around the world, in the Philippines, everywhere. They said there are three outcomes: either that party actually releases the hostage, or that party doesn't respond, as in the case of Gilad Shalit, or shortly after the appeal, a body turns up.

​

So we decided that our specific, individual appeals would not go to those mechanisms, unless it was a collective appeal on behalf of all the hostages. Other civil society bodies acted on behalf of all the hostages, and it was right for them to act with a general call. We made that call too, but not on behalf of any individual.

​

The individual details we passed on confidentially, never to be disclosed, so no one would be exposed: to humanitarian bodies, to the diplomatic presence in Israel, and to the mechanisms themselves at the UN. Behind the scenes, always with the families' consent of course, we also passed details to other civil society bodies that did write reports, whether about people with disabilities held in captivity and their needs, or about helping the elderly get released, or against enforced disappearance, but again without revealing individual details. It was a more general appeal, not an individual one.

​

The individual information we passed on directly to international prosecutors and international investigators, who issue arrest warrants, and whose expertise is fighting terrorism, crimes against humanity, genocide and war crimes. They have all the information on, for example, the 37 people we represented directly as early as October 15.

​

[30:50] The International Criminal Court

​

Yael: You asked about October 15, and what the first legal action was, beyond signing powers of attorney and making information accessible to victims. On October 15 I submitted the first request to the International Criminal Court in The Hague. I said: you have jurisdiction, I represent the people here, they are entitled, they want justice. Here are the crimes that were committed, here are the names of the people, here is who committed these crimes very openly, here are the names of the militias, here are figures speaking openly, here are some things that are visible to you too, and the rest you can find out elsewhere. And we are available to you.

​

That was on October 15. On October 31, and from November, I had direct meetings with investigators of the International Criminal Court. I gave them completely confidential evidence that UN mechanisms have no access to. All the more public work, in reports, is important, under a category called fact-finding reports, essentially factual reports. The best work they can do feeds into the investigations that we are advancing directly, and also sets, for example, sanctions at the UN. So we cooperate with these bodies and think it's very positive work, but it still doesn't lead directly to criminal accountability, or civil, or corporate, or state accountability, or that of non-state armed groups. It can lead to sanctions.

​

Part of our work, for example, made it into the UN Secretary-General's report, when in 2025 it determined that Hamas committed sexual crimes systematically as part of the fighting. Our work was one of three sources cited in that report. The source I'm referring to is the May 2024 application by the Court's Prosecutor to issue three arrest warrants against three senior Hamas leaders, who have since been killed in the fighting, so those warrants became essentially moot. But at least the arrest warrants state that Hamas committed sexual crimes systematically, in a way that amounts to crimes against humanity. We achieved that. We are continuing the work toward more arrest warrants, against more militias and more acts, and against the living, those still alive who still influence these crimes.

​

Inbal: Since we're talking about The Hague, that's an organization with a lot of politicization, and decisions against senior Israeli officials. And you come from the other side and say, wait, justice also has to be pursued against the other side. Did you feel any kind of clash?

​

Yael: Thank you very much. This question is a critical part of our work, and it got a lot of attention. The whole matter of the International Criminal Court and its place in the world, we could talk about scandals. Everything is political. For example, we know that the Court's Prosecutor was recently removed from office. States that are members of the Court decided to remove him, after he was accused of extremely serious acts of a sexual nature against an employee from his own office, a junior employee compared to him, the most powerful man in the role, if we're talking about an international public servant whose job is accountability.

​

Even this matter, involving a strong, powerful person, allegedly drunk on power, who committed terrible acts against his employee, got politicized. Some said it's actually the Mossad, Israel and the United States trying to oust him, and others said, no, he issued arrest warrants only because of the charges against him. Let's say his credibility was damaged, because any person with power who can be compromised can be blackmailed. He's vulnerable, so he's problematic, his judgment is impaired, and he can no longer claim to have no conflict of interest.

​

The question is how we operate, October 7 Justice Without Borders, in the international arena, whether in Germany, France, Israel, the United States, or at the International Criminal Court, all the more so because the politicization is even stronger there. I'll say that we have acted, from day one, through the rights, in the name of the rights, and only the rights, of the victims we represent: the right to justice, the right to truth, the right to reparations, the right to never again, within a framework based on existing rules and laws. That is what we demand of ourselves, and certainly of a judicial mechanism.

​

We like to say that the only brand we promote is Unconditional Humanity, humanity without conditions. All we are doing is implementing existing law for those harmed on October 7.

So I turned, on October 15, to the unit whose job is to protect victims at the International Criminal Court. On October 31, I formally approached the Prosecutor of the Court to open a formal request, given that the Prosecutor has no access to the victims themselves, and within the Court there is a kind of Chinese wall of protection and confidentiality. After that, from November, the investigation proceeded efficiently and actively, and in May 2024 the Prosecutor requested, unfortunately, five arrest warrants. In the same breath, he sought an arrest warrant against the Prime Minister and against Yoav Gallant, the former Defense Minister, alongside three Hamas leaders: Sinwar, Haniyeh and Mohammed Deif.

​

How did we act? First of all, to fight this false symmetry, because there is no symmetry here at all. We don't speak politically; we are not a political body, we are a legal body. Legally, these are separate cases, separate files, factually, legally and evidentially. We also wrote to the judges and asked for complete separation between these cases. We succeeded somewhat: the arrest warrants that were unfortunately issued against the Prime Minister and Yoav Gallant were issued on the same day as the arrest warrant against Mohammed Deif, but in separate announcements. That may seem like nothing, but it is very significant, both for the victims and globally in terms of public perception. From my point of view, the announcement of the warrant against Mohammed Deif makes no mention of anything relating to the State of Israel or to our Prime Minister.

​

In addition, when they tried to wrap everything in the same package, they made the victims I represent invisible. On that day in May 2024, fifteen journalists approached me, from abroad and from Israel, and asked me only one question: what did I think of the arrest warrant being sought against the Prime Minister of the State of Israel. That announcement shocked me deeply, at a time when Israel was in its darkest hour, its existential hour.

​

I say it unconditionally, as a matter of humanity: if the Prime Minister needs to stand trial, I don't want to see any Israeli prime minister stand trial abroad. If crimes like these were committed, I want justice done in Israel, by the way, and then let justice be done. But this announcement shocked me deeply, professionally and personally, because it came out before all procedures were exhausted, and the investigation against the Prime Minister was cut short. We know this was criticized even by the Biden administration, so this isn't some politicization one can dismiss.

​

The Court's investigators were about to board a flight to Israel to speak with the main suspect from the Court's point of view, while the Prosecutor announced the arrest warrant. You don't issue an arrest warrant against a main suspect before exhausting the investigation against him. Meanwhile, the crimes and materials the Court held, from materials we passed on, from other sources, and from its own independent investigation, are perhaps the most filmed and documented crimes in human history. There was enough material, and those three arrest warrants should have been issued immediately, and certainly not bundled together with suspicions of crimes committed on the Israeli side.

​

I try to understand the psychology of the people acting here, because ultimately they want to ensure the continuity of that international court as an institution. In their psychology, when they announce arrest warrants, they are declaring that no one is above the law. And I tell them, no, that's not what you declared. You declared that you are unprofessional and that your discretion is compromised. Do what needs to be done, and if something more is needed, do it, but in the most professional way, because you are treading on the most political and explosive ground there is. So tread carefully and make sure you have a solid case.

​

For example, the arrest warrant against the Prime Minister was issued for starvation, yet not a single international organization today has recognized that there was starvation in Gaza. Yes, there was an acute humanitarian crisis, and no, I wouldn't trade places with any Palestinian in Gaza during the war. I don't think any of us would choose to be there, nor would the hostages who were there and endured the bombardments. But there was no starvation, so how can there be a starvation crime, I ask professionally.

​

Maybe I'll sum up your question of how we navigate a highly political arena: we navigate it through law. Law has power over politics, and the reverse is also true, by the way. Just as there is military power, political power and legal power. The military arena is not enough, the political arena is not enough. The legal arena enjoys legitimacy and has a power that other fronts lack. We base ourselves first of all on victims' rights, and when a political actor stands before me, I say: please look into the eyes of the girl I represent, or that elderly woman or man who lost everything, and tell them anything you want to say that doesn't relate directly to their rights and to the criminal responsibility of those who carried out, sent, or still collaborate with those atrocities.

​

[43:10] Fighting denial through the law

​

Inbal: In this context, I'd like to raise your exposure to the whole phenomenon of denial. There was massive denial, and documentation of the testimonies ultimately serves as an evidentiary basis for trials. So how does international law help fight the wave of October 7 denial, which we can see spreading easily around the world? Even though there were videos and documentation, there are still those who don't believe it really happened. How can such a trial help us?

​

Yael: Law has critical power against denial. Denial is one of the three arms of the harm we define as the October 7 harm, three years on. The first harm is the atrocities themselves, the bloody, murderous attack itself. The second harm is denial. The third harm is the result of the first two: the overexposure of victims.

​

By the way, we want to ensure that in the trials we can hopefully protect victims' rights against overexposure better than in the past three years, especially during the campaign to free the hostages, which was a campaign to save lives. There was overexposure, there was press, a country or society that on one hand wants to fight denial, and on the other hand must remember that the harm belongs first of all to the victims, and only then to Israeli society, which was obviously harmed too. Justice is due to all of us, but first of all to the victims.

​

So, how does law help against denial? Denial is mainly carried out through narrative campaigns of fake news on social media. Of course you can respond with the same tool. The problem is that this tool is known to be biased, and the information only reaches those who want to hear it; that's how algorithms are set up. Also, such information fades within twenty seconds. You've seen the reels, it's just as fleeting. Law anchors the truth in a binding, authoritative way, for generations.

That's why it's important that the law be as strong as possible. Not show trials for the sake of revenge, but trials like the Eichmann trial, like the Nuremberg trials. There's no doubt that behind them were suffering, hatred, a great need for justice, but what made the difference was the trial. The trials must be just trials, whether you believe in it ideologically or out of interest. They must be fair trials, because then they can do their job against denial.

​

It's always easier to explain through the Nuremberg trials. There's a strange phenomenon, and we've talked about it before: the breakdown of trust is so acute toward the international community, or vis-a-vis the international community in Israel, and even distrust toward bodies in Israel, though here at home we're still fighting. And there is distrust, rightly so, toward the murderous forces that rise up to destroy us, stand against us and don't want us to be here. The result of this reality of distrust is that, absurdly and tragically, we forget to demand accountability from those most culpable. We're not talking only about who is responsible, but who is most culpable for the acts.

​

After World War II, at the Nuremberg trials, there were Holocaust deniers, and in the sixties, seventies and eighties, and even in 2026. By the way, in those hate campaigns around October 7, somewhere you'll see Nazi symbols. It's all intertwined. But against all the hatred and denial stand the Nuremberg trials, for generations: first the trials themselves, the standing they gained in international law, and the defense given to the accused. Some were acquitted, and that's very good, because it means whoever was convicted was justly convicted. And after Nuremberg we have eighty years of such trials.

​

That's true for the victims in Bosnia, of sexual violence against tens of thousands of women, who have trials today, and for the victims of the Srebrenica genocide, where there are rulings convicting Karadzic and Mladic. They were brought to trial, whether around 2000, or a year or two after the atrocities, or twenty years later. But that justice was done, for societies still rebuilding themselves, and these trials help those broken societies rise back on their feet after atrocity and horror. Today it's Ukraine, Eritrea and other places suffering from this, and Israel too. We want to rebuild.

​

So first of all, against denial, for generations: October 7 trials, which in my view must take place in Israel first, that's the primary arena, but not only in Israel. We want fair trials in France, Germany, the United States and elsewhere. In January 2027 we expect the first criminal trial to take place in the United States. I don't know if that's a scoop, but we're part of this effort and very much looking forward to it. And then, once there are well-founded convictions, the argument of those deniers won't be only with the State of Israel and its justice system, but with courts around the world. Go ahead and simply deny the truth. We'll understand that your problem isn't with Israel, it's with the truth. So deal with the truth. Law has this power to recognize the truth very forcefully.

​

Inbal: I completely agree with what you said. Of course I asked you that question, but for me it was rhetorical. I firmly believe that once this stands before courts worldwide, we can no longer call it one big conspiracy. Everything circulating online gets shaken a bit, and the goal is really to open people's eyes, to understand what's really happening, and that today it's us, tomorrow it could be anyone.

​

[50:05] Sexual violence and crimes in captivity

​

Trigger warning: this section discusses sexual violence.

​

Inbal: For my next question, I first want to add a trigger warning, because we'll be discussing the sexual violence that occurred on October 7. Anyone who finds this segment hard to listen to can skip ahead. But it's a necessary question. On October 7, sexual violence took place on Israeli soil, but there is evidence and conclusive testimony that gender-based violence and sexual abuse continued in captivity in Gaza. How do you create a legal continuum linking the atrocities of the massacre day with the ongoing crimes committed in the tunnels of Gaza?

​

Yael: First of all, it's important to anchor the fact that on the day of the massacre, in different scenes at the same time, crimes of a sexual nature were committed. That means it was systematic. Another thing to establish is that sex crimes are never committed in a vacuum. It's not that everything around is calm and somehow there are sex crimes. I'm talking now about a massive attack, of course, not about what we might call domestic sexual crime, which unfortunately, as we all know, is far too common. Here too there are gaps.

​

We're now talking about the international arena, where crimes are committed as part of a systematic or widespread attack against a civilian population, or where crimes of a sexual nature are committed in the context of war. Those are two situations: one is called war crimes, the other is called crimes against humanity. It can even amount to genocide if it's proven that, in the perpetrators' eyes, these sexual crimes were part of an attack aimed at destroying a group, wholly or partly. We are in that arena, but it's harder to prove.

​

So first, establish that on the day of the massacre this was done, because it was done. We know it was done, and there are strong indications. We don't know exact numbers; much is still hidden, and it may take years, perhaps decades, until survivors come forward and speak about it. Perhaps witnesses, who were also harmed by witnessing these human atrocities, will decide they want to speak about it, so that the price of speaking becomes smaller than the price of silence. We hope that happens, and above all we hope these people take care of themselves. They are what matters most.

​

So, anchor the reality of October 7 and understand that it was carried out as part of a plan, not randomly, but as part of the indoctrination these people underwent, so that when they crossed the border they were not just human beings; they had been indoctrinated that everything is permitted, even a commandment. If you want, you can find some religious-ideological basis that the perpetrators invent for that purpose. That's important.

​

Then, clearly, the abduction itself, the very act of taking a person from their home, abducting them, making them disappear, tying them up, shackling them and holding them against their will: these are, as I mentioned at the start of the podcast, continuing crimes, meaning they're directly linked to the original crime, the October 7 attack. They are part of the attack. That's why the law the Knesset passed for a military tribunal to try the terrorists in Jerusalem, the law of May 11, passed by a large majority of 93 Knesset members from the opposition and coalition together, speaks of the October 7 crimes committed on and since October 7.

​

So all crimes committed against hostages, and by the way also against their families, psychological terror or psychological torture, are crimes in every sense, and they form a continuum. We have no legal difficulty proving that continuum. It's clear to us from the testimonies of especially brave women and men, who spoke very discreetly and didn't reveal even a quarter of what they went through, that abuse was carried out, sexual, psychological and physical, amounting to torture and cruel, degrading and inhuman treatment.

​

And we see a system here, because there were commanders, call them captors, who knew this would happen, or committed the acts themselves, or their subordinates did, so that's part of the system. There are also cases, indications from testimonies we hear, where hostages, mostly female hostages, were subjected to such acts in secret. Then the question is whether their commanders bear responsibility if the perpetrator hid it from them. That's a fair question. The answer is that the commander who placed those people in that situation exposed them to abuse, and therefore those commanders bear criminal responsibility, both direct and indirect. I hope I answered without being too triggering.

​

Inbal: Honestly, it raised many more questions for me, but it's an extremely complex topic. I truly hope the victims find the strength over time to bring their testimonies forward and give them expression, especially within the amazing framework you've built, to really bring justice, and how incredibly significant and important that is. Because as you said, the attack began on October 7 but it continued in the tunnels of Gaza, and I think that's what the world somewhat forgot. They treated it as one day, when in fact for every Israeli citizen and every person in the Jewish community, that day lasted over two years.

​

[56:50] Trust, confidentiality and who counts as a victim

 

Yael: Since you mentioned the hope that victims will come forward and tell their story, I do want to say, because there's a lot in the media: we really work directly. Our business is not to expose anyone to the media. First of all, we're here for the long run. October 7 Justice Without Borders is here, and we're not going anywhere until we achieve our goals: anchoring the truth in trials, justice, compensation, and hopefully a long-term impact so these things don't repeat.

​

Second, the work is discreet, as discreet as can be, covered by privilege. People sign a power of attorney with me, so there's attorney-client privilege. If someone was harmed and wants to talk, they can talk, even just for a consultation. There's nothing binding, and we can figure out what options suit them. Some will want to give testimony directly, and I won't bring any journalist into it. Some will want to record testimony and we can pass it on under privilege. There are all kinds of ways to speak and bring out the truth without being exposed, or perhaps wanting to be exposed but under certain conditions. There are creative ways, and the main thing for us is the victim, man or woman. That's what matters most to us. This is a matter of life and death. We're a life-and-death startup.

​

Inbal: It was very important that you clarified that point, because it conveys that this is a safe space, a discreet safe space. The testimony comes to you, and the victim has control to decide whether or not to disclose it, or in what way. I definitely recommend that if you choose to make your story or testimony public, you do it with an organization that supports you properly, like you offer, with the paramount importance of bringing justice to these people and knowing they're in good, discreet hands.

​

Now, non-profit representation of almost 500 victims, including survivors, hostages, bereaved families and more, all at no cost. How do you build trust with people who went through such severe trauma, so they join and become part of the process? And who can actually come forward and say "I was harmed"? There may be people who were secondarily harmed and don't know they can also be part of the lawsuit. Walk us through it.

​

Yael: Great. Today we stand at 478 victims, going on 481, because we have three more about to sign, and we're talking with another 15 who are interested. You asked about trust and who counts as a victim. When people ask me what our successes are, first of all I point to the trust we've earned from day one, directly from the victims, consistently over the past three years, from people who truly lost everything, but still get up and keep going and still give strength to our team. Amazing people. They even strengthen us and lift our spirits every day.

​

This trust is something that's built, it's earned. We say what we do, and we say what we don't do. We keep our word. We also make mistakes, and we say, here was a mistake, here we'll fix it. We're very transparent; we operate with full transparency and confidentiality. We have media work we must do so the world understands, so awareness grows of our work and the importance of justice. But we never reveal who we represent unless the client tells us again and again, "this is part of my journey."

​

For example, at some point we said, and we say it, that we represent, and it's such a huge privilege, the family of Shani Louk, and the memory of Shani Louk, of blessed memory, Ricarda, Nissim, and Shani Louk's siblings. We say it openly because it's the Louk family's journey to justice. But many people tell us, no problem, say it, and we still don't, because we want to check whether exposure is in the best interest of people in trauma or not. And if it's truly what they want, then we disclose.

​

We accompany truly amazing people, salt of the earth. You hear that phrase a lot, but I think I only discovered its true meaning on and since October 7, and certainly with our clients. Amazing people, people over 65, say, elderly people in their eighties, who give me hope every day and show me perspective, show me what suffering is and what resilience is, what healing of mind and body is, what rebuilding is. We see people of a certain age calling out to their communities, saying, guys, wake up, we're going back to the kibbutz, we're rebuilding. Others understand those who can't go back and make room for them too, which is also fine, by the way. There are also nonprofits founded by victims themselves to help and support victims who realize they won't return to live in the same place.

​

So the trust we have is daily, over three years, which to me is a huge achievement, over a thousand days. These are different layers of the population: people from Sderot and Ofakim and from the kibbutzim in the south, some better known like Nir Oz, Be'eri, Nahal Oz, Nir Yitzhak or Kissufim, and some a bit less known like Ein HaShlosha, Holit, Netiv HaAsara and other places. We represent people from 20 different crime scenes, and from the parties. Everyone talks about Nova, and we know there was also Psyduck, Midburn and other gatherings.

​

We represent these people in direct contact. We're not a factory; we keep a human connection. We're always trying to streamline communication with people. We send periodic updates to the people we represent, and individual updates whenever we take direct action for a specific person. Proceedings, like investigations, are ongoing, so there isn't news every day, but if we passed on a certain person's information on a certain day, that person will get the information and know about it. They won't discover it in the newspaper, let's put it that way.

​

Another thing we do for trust is create some quiet in the chaos, because we're professionals. Some calm amid the noise. Instead of talking to 15 lawyers, we centralize everything with our partners around the world or in Israel. And people still approach our clients, and victims in general, in a way that I'm sure is well-meaning, but not always responsible. For example, there was a recent approach: we want to do an entitlement check, give us your details, it'll cost you 600 shekels, it's a discreet check, and then we'll pursue entitlements against bodies that reward terrorism. That's called civil lawsuits. Okay, so tell people you're working with and connected to lawyers, tell them transparently, and that if they respond, it's to file lawsuits. I don't see that in what someone I represent sent me yesterday, and I really looked. I believe information should be highlighted very clearly and transparently. That's it, and it proves itself.

​

Another thing: we don't go out recruiting. We're not missionaries saying come to us. People approach us by word of mouth. Most are in certain communities. Sometimes someone takes initiative and says, I have to tell you, say a woman in a group of bereaved families from the parties, I have to tell you about someone who's been with us since day one. We didn't ask her to, and it's amazing. And then another 150 people approached us and we took them on, those who were interested, of course.

​

For us, success is when victims know what they're choosing and also what they're not choosing. It's fine if they approach us and decide at the end of the process it's not right for them. To me that's a real success, because then I sleep well at night knowing we're doing the best work for them with integrity, and for this lofty collective goal.

​

Who counts as a victim? Whoever survived, whoever sadly didn't survive, and first-degree relatives, whether heirs or dependents of that person or simply first-degree family members, are entitled to representation. Whoever was abducted and released, whoever was abducted and not released alive, and their families. We also have the issue of digital terrorism harm, which we're working on together with civil society partners to amend legislation so they're recognized as victims of hostile acts, victims of digital terrorism. That's more work we're doing. To us they're victims and they can reach out.

​

If you're a victim, or you have doubts, you're welcome to contact us. We'll do an assessment and give you a direct and useful answer, whether representation is relevant or not, including what we don't do. For example, we don't deal with National Insurance, but at best we can direct you to bodies that do represent people there. We get nothing in return and have no interest, but we know these are bodies, for example legal clinics or civil society organizations, that act before National Insurance at no cost for social justice. That's the matter of trust and who counts as a victim.

​

Inbal: I think that's very, very important. Ultimately, every citizen of Israel was harmed that day, but sadly not all of us can go to an international court and demand justice. So there are the direct victims, and the remarkable organization behind them that does this for all of us, because we were all harmed that day. If anyone has any doubt, how can they find out whether they're included or not, and whether it's right for them to join the remarkable community you've built?

 

[1:08:15] How you can help

​

Inbal: Before we wrap up, Justice Without Borders, the stage is yours. It's been a wonderful hour and I have many more questions, but we'll stop here. What matters to me is how we, as listeners, as communities in Israel and around the world, can contribute to the continuation of your important volunteer work.

​

Yael: Thank you so much, Inbal, thank you for the platform and for the podcast. I listened to earlier episodes that really touched me, so I was very glad to join.

​

We know how to do the professional work, but we can't do it alone. We don't charge victims anything, and we want this to continue for the long haul. Our model of work includes criminal accountability; action before UN human rights mechanisms; collecting and building the evidentiary foundation, whether directly from victims or from investigative authorities in Israel, like the National Institute of Forensic Medicine, transferring materials that form the basis for legal action; and promoting policy. That policy work covers the response to sexual crimes, the digital space as a space of accountability, expanding rights and recognizing more victims, and how to prosecute the Nukhba crimes in Israel in line with the rules of evidence, with representation of the victims, ensuring their rights are taken into account before, during and after the proceedings, and making sure there are fair trials here that the world will listen to, and not dismiss.

​

There are already attempts to smear this work. We do all of this at no cost. It's important for me to say, in full transparency, that we pursue the civil lawsuits alongside partners who cover all the costs, all of them, and take on all the risks. Even if they lose, they put millions out of their own pocket, and at the end of the process they take a success fee, not us. That's in a separate contract, by the way, so anyone who signs a power of attorney with us is not obligated at all to file the civil suits with them. These are very broad suits, filed against the Palestinian Authority and Hamas, but also against banks, financiers, crypto entities and other parties.

​

All of this work, including the Louk family's case against AP and Reuters, which is a call for anyone directly harmed, and a case in the District Court for only five families at the moment. As you said, all legal work is directly for the victims but also for everyone, and we do all of it at no cost, as a non-profit, pro bono.

​

We need to keep going so we can be in every arena at the right time: in the United States in January and September, on September 15 in Europe, in Bonn, and on October 5 in Chicago, to speak about the sexual violence. We need to be in every arena with the right tools, with lawyers, investigators, analysts and experts, paying terrorism experts to tell us where Hamas and Islamic Jihad are in Germany, Austria and Italy. We need funding. We know how to do the work, but we can't do it alone, and everyone here has the power to contribute, whether a one-time donation or more. Even a monthly donation of 120 shekels a month gives us some stability.

​

If we have a hundred people, a thousand people donating from their own pockets, we estimate the annual cost of representing each victim at about 5,500 shekels a year, over three years. So think about whether any of you ever needed something from a lawyer, whether representation to get a foreign passport, or status issues, or a labor law dispute, or a dispute with a landlord, and think about how much that cost you. What we do is truly the bare minimum, not so we profit from it, but so we can continue to be here, because we intend to be here for the long term.

​

You can donate. We have a website: october7justice.org. Go to our donation page. Donations in Israel go through a recognized link with Section 46 tax approval. Right now, thanks to Matan, who helps us, many thanks to Matan, it's a direct link. You can make a one-time or monthly donation, which helps us even more. For larger donations, we invite you to contact me. All the details are on the website. My email is yael\@october7justice.org. You can also contact me with questions.​​

​

And by the way, you can contribute in other ways besides money, by following us on Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram and Twitter, and by sharing the message. You spread it, you create awareness of the need for justice that is non-political and independent, purely in the name of the humanity each of us needs. It's very important to emphasize: we are not political. I hope this encourages anyone who's tired of the very political arena, of our very political reality today in Israel and in the world. It's very important to have an independent body. We don't receive government funds; we're independent of any government body. And we need this support to keep doing what we'll keep doing for the long term. Thank you very much.

​

[1:16:00] Closing

​

Inbal: You're welcome. And of course we'll add all the links, the email address and the social media links to the episode notes, so anyone who missed it can find it there and easily reach October 7 Justice. If you have trouble, you can contact us on our social media and we'll connect you. Justice Without Borders, attorney Yael Vias Gvirsman. I said it right? Yael Vias Gvirsman. Thank you so much, I knew I'd get tangled up with it, but I did my best.

​

I think you're all doing wonderful, meaningful work, you and the remarkable women standing beside you. I take my hat off to you and I'm proud of you. I look forward to following your work, and of course we here at A Voice of Hope will keep following and supporting your work. Thank you so much for what is shaping up to truly be our voice of hope in international law, for every citizen of Israel who on that day saw, was harmed, absorbed it, and to this day is trying to process what really happened that day. Thank you so much, Yael, for the precious time you gave us.

​

Yael: Thank you so much, Inbal, and thank you to A Voice of Hope. I invite everyone to join us. It's important.

​

Inbal: Thank you very much. This was A Voice of Hope, from hardship to growth. I'm Inbal Tzarfati Cohen. You can find us on Spotify or Apple Podcasts, and on social media, on Facebook or Instagram. Links will be in the episode notes. We'd be glad if you follow us and rate us highly, and if you enjoyed it, share it with a friend. Requests and suggestions for episodes can be sent by email.

​

Thank you for listening. See you in the next episode of A Voice of Hope.

bottom of page