O7J Podcast
The Elephant in the Room
Speakers
-
Udi Goren – Host
-
Abraham Abu Ahmed – Host
-
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman – Guest, founder of October 7 Justice Without Borders
00:00 | What is transitional justice?Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
The definition of transitional justice is the ability – the courage – to look at the pain of the past while facing forwards. You need both of these elements. If we look at the past only in order to punish and kill in another way – not on the battlefield, but through legal proceedings – that is not transitional justice. If we want to acknowledge the truth in order to move towards something new and better, that is transitional justice.
00:26 | Introduction: The October 7 attack and what comes next
Abraham Abu Ahmed:
Hello, and welcome to another episode of our podcast, The Elephant in the Room. This is the podcast where the two of us, Israeli citizens – me, Abraham, a Palestinian, and my Jewish friend Udi – sit together and talk about the elephant in the room: all the things that nobody wants to address in Israeli society and in the streets here in Israel.
We want to open up these subjects because this is the only way to move towards a better future. Udi, it's good to have you.
Udi Goren:
Thank you. We're recording this episode and broadcasting it during the week of October 7, three years after the catastrophe that changed all our lives.
For me personally, it completely changed the course I was on. I went from being a photographer and tour guide to putting that world largely aside. For two years, I focused almost entirely on the campaign for the hostages. During that time, I decided to remain involved in public advocacy, because there is so much that needs to be repaired. We all saw that, and I saw it from the inside.
Looking back over these three years, that has become very clear. But today, we don't want to focus on the catastrophe of October 7 itself. That's easy. October 7 brought disaster upon Jews and Arabs within Israel who were affected by it. It brought disaster upon the region and shattered the entire regional fabric. There is no need to elaborate on that.
Today, I want us to discuss October 7 and where we go from here.
One of the first major things we did as part of the hostage campaign was, at the beginning of 2024, to do something that the State of Israel itself could not do. We travelled to The Hague to sue Hamas. We represented the families, with the aim of pursuing Hamas financially, preventing its members from travelling freely, including from Qatar, and initiating legal and diplomatic measures that the State of Israel could not undertake.
Today, I want our conversation to connect with the discussion of international law. But, as I said, the more important question is where we go next. After the trauma and the catastrophe, how can we repair things?
Host:
Where does that leave you?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Of course I remember that trip to The Hague. We went to represent the victims, and while we were there, we heard that another hostage deal that had been under discussion was being blocked.
But that's not actually what I want to tell you about. I want to tell you about the first week of the war.
I entered this period having already spent many years studying conflicts: how long-term ethnic conflicts work, how they end, and so on. I have ideas about this, and you can even look me up online and see what I was saying during the first week of the war.
I said that a terrible catastrophe had taken place. Whoever committed crimes, whoever did wrong, whoever sinned, must be held accountable. But afterwards, we would have an opportunity to change Israel's narrative.
Long-term ethnic conflicts are resolved in one of two ways. Either extraordinary leaders emerge who are willing to put the interests of their country and people before their own personal interests. We had one such leader, and he was murdered. Anyone who wanted to continue along that path could see what happened.
The other possibility is that enormous catastrophes occur, causing both peoples to understand that enough is enough.
And we were at that point. Just one week into the events, I recognised that this could be the moment when, five years from now, we look back and say that October 7 marked the beginning of a change in direction that brought an end to the violence between the river and the sea.
But that depends entirely on us.
There is a clear political theory suggesting that solutions can emerge from the most difficult circumstances, including war. There is often a window of five to seven years. You don't even need to look outside Israel to see examples of this. Our own history provides them.
In 1973, we fought a war with Egypt. Who would have imagined that, just five years later, an Egyptian leader would come to Israel and a peace agreement would be signed?
The same applies to the First Intifada in 1987. Who thought that five years later we would be talking about Oslo? The agreement was signed in 1993, and a year later Israel signed a peace agreement with Jordan.
Rabin was assassinated in 1995. Five years later, we had the Camp David summit. Who would have believed that could happen after his assassination?
In 2002, the Second Intifada came to an end. Five years later, we had the Annapolis conference between Olmert and Abu Mazen.
This five-year pattern has appeared in our history. Sometimes leaders took the process all the way and signed agreements, as happened with Egypt and Jordan. At other times, we came close, but lacked the courage to do what was necessary and sign an agreement between Israelis and Palestinians.
Udi Goren:
I completely agree. Those are extraordinary examples, and the way you frame them is very important.
What was missing in those agreements was the public. They were agreements made by leaders. The public wasn't really part of the process and didn't come along with them.
Today, we want to talk with our guest about how we can change the public narrative, repair the damage and move forward.
06:45 | Introducing Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman and October 7 Justice Without Borders
Abraham Abu Ahmed:
Our guest today is Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman, founder of October 7 Justice Without Borders and an expert in international law and transitional justice.
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Hello!
Udi Goren:
Hello, Yael. We're going to look at what you've been doing, particularly over the past three years since October 7.
Let's take it slowly, because we're going back over some very difficult material. Tell us what you did after October 7. What is the project you established, and why?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
All right. The project is called October 7 Justice Without Borders.
I've been a lawyer for 20 years, working in areas affected by atrocities and conflict. My work involves pursuing justice and accountability – criminal and civil – before courts and other bodies, in order to secure recognition through legal processes and help societies move from conflict towards peace.
Udi Goren:
I can already hear our listeners losing concentration! What you're saying sounds very good, but let's make it more concrete. Can you give us an example of what this actually looks like?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
First, I should explain what led me to act after October 7. But to answer your question about what we actually do, it involves the direct representation of victims.
It means going to places such as Be'eri, Nir Yitzhak, Kfar Aza and other communities, and approaching prosecutors whose expertise is in crimes against humanity.
We approach them in our capacity as legal representatives and say: I represent these people. They have suffered crimes that fall within your jurisdiction. You have the authority to investigate and prosecute everyone responsible: those who directly carried out the crimes, those who sent them, those who designed and organised the atrocities, and those who collaborated with them – including people who continue to collaborate today.
That applies whether they are in Gaza, in Israel or elsewhere in the world.
What happened on October 7 did not originate on October 7, or even in Gaza. If we have armed militias causing mass civilian suffering – in Gaza as well as in Israel, even today – it is clear that they are supported by a wider global network. Some of these connections are in countries we know about, such as Qatar and Turkey, but others are in democracies around the world.
Udi Goren:
That's beginning to make the work more concrete. But what exactly did your project do?
I think many people assume that Hamas is a recognised terrorist organisation, that we were attacked by terrorists, and that the State of Israel supports victims of terrorist attacks. But there is no obvious address to turn to. There isn't a Hamas office waiting to receive complaints.
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Exactly. The law doesn't mean that we go to the people who committed the crimes and ask them to fix things or pay for what they did. Instead, we go to courts and other legal bodies that can make binding decisions, based on systems of law agreed upon by individual states or by the international community.
Those laws establish red lines. They identify certain acts as unacceptable – not merely immoral, but criminal – and establish that there must be consequences.
Sometimes, we become so familiar with the enemy in front of us, with the murderous organisation or individuals who have organised themselves to carry out these acts, that we stop expecting anything from the legal system.
But let's start with the basics: in a functioning legal system, those who commit horrific crimes must pay for them and be held accountable.
11:19 | The first days after October 7: Victims, families and displaced communities
Udi Goren:
So, you enter this situation after October 7. What are you doing on October 8 or October 10?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
The first people approached me, and then dozens, and eventually hundreds.
Initially, they were ordinary citizens who had volunteered to help displaced people or families of those who were missing. There were approximately 3,000 missing people from the kibbutzim, the festivals, Sderot and Ofakim.
There was complete chaos. And, incidentally, that chaos had been deliberately planned. Those who infiltrated Israel had planned to create as much human suffering and disorder as possible.
It took weeks, and in some cases even months, to identify people who were missing. At the same time, families did not know whether their loved ones had been murdered on October 7 or taken hostage.
There were also entire communities whose homes had been destroyed or burned down, leaving people displaced. That was another part of the chaos.
In the first weeks, approximately 330,000 people were displaced, first from the south and then from the north, because there were several fronts.
There was the military front, but there was also a legal front and a campaign to shape the narrative and deny what had happened, which began on October 7.
People started contacting me. I was in Tel Aviv, which was also under attack by thousands of rockets targeting civilians. My sister lived in one of the kibbutzim, about nine kilometres from the border, and we had no contact with her for 48 hours.
During that time, citizens who were volunteering to help displaced people and families who did not know where their loved ones were began approaching me. At first, they asked me to connect them with the Red Cross, because it is a humanitarian organisation that might be able to help transfer information about hostages and identify people who had been abducted.
Then, on October 10, I was approached again with a very clear request: would I agree to speak with these people?
No one was speaking to them. No government body, no army representative, no police officer. All the efforts were directed towards fighting.
Udi Goren:
When you say “them”, do you mean the Red Cross?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
No, I mean the victims and the displaced people.
No one was speaking to the displaced people. Tens of thousands of people had been evacuated or were missing. The efforts were understandably focused on the fighting and clearing the area.
There were also reports of people being killed when they returned to their homes – sometimes simply to tend to their cows in the dairy farm, even three days after the attack.
The other major effort, apart from the fighting, was identifying the missing: who was alive, who was dead and who had been taken hostage.
There might be some contact with the authorities to take DNA samples, for example, or to knock on someone's door and deliver the news. Sometimes the news was that someone had been abducted; sometimes it was that they had been killed on October 7.
That's how it began. Once the second wave of requests came in, dozens and then hundreds of people began contacting me.
There were thousands and hundreds of thousands of extraordinary Israeli civilian volunteers. I was on calls around the clock. People wanted to collect testimonies.
I told them that if they did not have the necessary background or training, it would be better not to collect testimonies themselves. They might unintentionally cause further trauma. We needed to preserve the information and document what had happened, but we also had to be careful about how we did it.
Various civilian initiatives were emerging at the time. We all remember those efforts.
On October 11, I organised a Zoom meeting. A former student of mine, who was part of the legal clinic at Reichman University that I established and have managed since 2014, contacted me. The clinic had been created to respond to atrocities and similar situations in places such as Ukraine, China, Sierra Leone and elsewhere.
I wrote to the law students at Reichman University: “I hope you are all safe. I don't know exactly what I'm going to do, but I'm going to do something. If you're interested in helping, please contact me privately.”
Two wonderful students, Naomi and Aya, got in touch and said they were there to help.
Aya created the first Google document, which to this day serves as a place where victims can securely submit their details. The system records a timestamp showing when each person submitted their information.
Naomi helped me prepare the Zoom meeting: how to conduct it securely, how to transfer information and how to protect it. Everything was extremely sensitive. We needed to act, but we also needed to protect people and safeguard their information for the future.
Udi Goren:
And how did this develop? What form did the project eventually take?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
I offered them pro bono legal representation, at no cost to them.
This representation was for victims: people who had been abducted, their families who could speak on their behalf, survivors, and the families of those who had been murdered and could no longer speak for themselves.
Udi Goren:
And who do you represent them before?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
I represent them before courts and what we might call quasi-judicial mechanisms. We'll discuss transitional justice later, but these mechanisms are important for establishing accountability for those who carried out the crimes, those who ordered them and those who collaborated with them.
This concerns anyone who bears direct criminal responsibility: someone who committed a specific act, with the necessary intention or knowledge. In other words, someone who knew, or should have known, that their actions contributed to terrorism, crimes against humanity, genocide or war crimes.
17:24 | The international courts: The ICC, the ICJ and international crimes
Udi Goren:
Let's pause for a technical question, but one that's extremely important for setting the scene. Most people have heard of the International Court in The Hague, but they may not realise that there are actually two different courts, what their respective roles are, and that other legal mechanisms are available.
Could you briefly explain this so that we all know what we're talking about?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Let's focus on the two main institutions. The first is the International Criminal Court, or ICC, which is based in The Hague. The second is the International Court of Justice, or ICJ, also based in The Hague. They are separate institutions, despite being located in the same city.
The ICJ is the court that deals with disputes between states. It is part of the United Nations system, which was established after the Second World War to help prevent atrocities from happening again and to create what is sometimes called a “long peace” – a transition from war to peace.
The ICC, on the other hand, was established much more recently, in 1998. It is the institution through which we are acting directly on behalf of the victims of October 7.
The key difference is that the ICC deals with the criminal responsibility of individuals, whereas the ICJ deals with disputes and responsibilities between states.
For example, South Africa brought Israel before the ICJ, arguing that Israel had violated the Genocide Convention. Under that convention, states have obligations to prevent and punish genocide.
Udi Goren:
So, to clarify for our listeners: at the ICC, Israel can take action against Hamas operatives or its leadership, whereas the ICJ is only concerned with states?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Let me clarify that. The ICC is essentially like a criminal court within a country, except that it operates internationally. Not everyone can bring a case there; there are strict procedural rules and requirements that must be met.
The ICC prosecutes individuals. Following the Nuremberg trials, the international community recognised that, if we wanted to prevent atrocities and ensure that genocide would never happen again, we needed to hold individuals accountable, not just states.
There is a prosecutor, just as there is a public prosecutor in Israel, but this is an international prosecution service.
Victims also have a direct role. They are not parties in the same way as the prosecution and defence, but they have rights to participate. They can have legal representatives who appear before the judges and represent their interests.
That is our role. We are waiting for the day when those responsible are arrested, and we are working to help bring that day about. We participate actively in investigations and engage with the Court's investigators, who prepare applications for arrest warrants. Judges then decide whether to issue those warrants.
When the individuals are eventually arrested and proceedings take place, we will represent the victims before the Court.
The ICJ is different. It deals with state responsibility. It is an alternative mechanism to war, or at least it is meant to be: when diplomacy fails and states want to avoid using military force, one state can bring a case against another state. It is not a case against an individual; it is a case about the responsibility of a sovereign state.
Udi Goren:
So Hamas itself is not a party to proceedings at the ICJ?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Correct. You cannot bring Hamas as an organisation before the ICJ. You can, however, pursue individuals associated with Hamas before the ICC.
We worked towards the ICC issuing arrest warrants against individuals responsible for the crimes. The Court issued warrants for Mohammed Deif and Yahya Sinwar, among others. In Deif's case, the Court later confirmed that he had died. The warrants concerned their responsibility as senior commanders for what Hamas had done.
The crimes included murder, rape and other forms of sexual violence, as well as widespread destruction. These acts may constitute war crimes and crimes against humanity.
The distinction between an ordinary crime – although we should never become accustomed to ordinary crimes, such as an individual murder, rape or robbery – and an international crime depends on the context.
Was it committed in the context of armed conflict? Was it part of a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population? Was it carried out with the intention of destroying all or part of a protected group?
These are the elements that distinguish, respectively, war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide. Each element must be established and proven.
23:30 | International public opinion, denial and politicisation
Udi Goren:
This is obviously a very long process, which began immediately after October 7.
While you have been working on it, global public opinion has changed. International perceptions of what is happening have shifted considerably over the past three years.
You mentioned the campaign that began almost immediately, attempting to deny what happened on October 7 and to change the narrative.
There was initially widespread support and empathy around the world for Israeli civilians. But three months, six months, a year or two years later, even countries that supported Israel on October 8 no longer necessarily did so.
How does that affect your work?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
It affects both public opinion and the way people around the world understand these events. The moral distinction between right and wrong has become blurred. It has become increasingly difficult for people to distinguish between victims and perpetrators.
Udi Goren:
In what sense?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
There are private companies that have identified, for example, 20,000 social media accounts that were created just days before October 7. These accounts simultaneously published thousands of identical messages, all of which were false. Some of those messages claimed that Israel was committing genocide on October 7, before Israel had even entered Gaza.
But this did not begin on October 7. It draws on at least 30 or 60 years of ideological and organisational infrastructure, including networks associated with the Muslim Brotherhood and others.
This is about narratives. It is about connecting a particular cause to the language of human rights and other struggles around the world: environmental protection, equality, and many other causes.
It is about attaching a particular political narrative to almost every struggle that people can imagine, particularly within the global post-colonial discourse.
You can see this in the way different movements and causes are connected. Even the struggle against apartheid in South Africa is part of this discussion. In fact, South Africa is also where some of the foundations of transitional justice emerged. White South Africans also fought against apartheid alongside Black South Africans.
The idea is to attach a particular cause to existing struggles in order to generate identification and win people's hearts and minds, particularly among young people, through social media.
That is the infrastructure on which the narrative surrounding October 7 was built. It can lead to absurd situations, such as a young person who genuinely cares about the environment wearing a slogan associated with a movement without understanding what it represents or what it is supporting.
Udi Goren:
I want to ask where you feel this has affected your work. Public opinion – whether among governments or ordinary people – and the work of a court should, in theory, be two separate things. A court should not be deciding cases according to public opinion or what happened in 2025, rather than what happened on October 7.
But somehow, the distinction seems to have become blurred. Does that affect what you do?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Absolutely.
First, let me explain what our work involves today. We represent 480 victims from 20 different nationalities. They include people from the kibbutzim, survivors and victims of the Nova festival, people from Ofakim and Sderot, and family members.
Our work involves pursuing criminal and civil accountability against the infrastructure of terrorism, including through UN human rights mechanisms. We seek recognition of specific crimes, such as torture, sexual crimes and forced displacement. We also work towards the protection of vulnerable populations, including children, women, people with disabilities and people aged 65 and over – people who were not spared from the violence.
Udi Goren:
And this work takes place before international tribunals and courts, both in Israel and abroad?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Let me finish explaining the effect of the wider environment. One of the major problems is over-politicisation: the desire to give everything we do, or do not do, a political label.
This existed before, but it has now been amplified enormously. And it affects our work in both directions.
Within Israel, people on both the left and the right ask questions based on their political assumptions. Outside Israel, the same happens among people who identify as pro-Israel or pro-Palestinian.
It also affects society internally, because people have developed a deep and significant lack of trust in international human rights mechanisms.
Udi Goren:
Which mechanisms are you referring to?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
The United Nations, for example. These are the institutions that helped turn the values established in the 1940s into an institutional system.
That includes the United Nations, the European Union, international human rights conventions and the wider network of institutions and legal mechanisms that developed after the Second World War, including the Nuremberg trials.
The first step was turning general principles into binding law. The second was moving beyond a system focused exclusively on sovereign states and recognising the individual as a rights-holder – including the victim.
The fact that I represent victims and can bring their cases before some of the most powerful international institutions is significant. We can ask those institutions to exercise their authority, investigate and prosecute.
At the same time, the individual perpetrator is placed at the centre of the process: the person who must answer for their actions and may spend the rest of their life in prison because of their contribution to the crimes.
Udi Goren:
What's interesting is that research also discusses a change in the way Palestinians present their cause internationally.
If we look back at the 1970s and 1980s, we can see that Israel enjoyed considerable international support, while the Palestinian movement often presented itself through the language of armed struggle and the image of the fighter. That approach did not work particularly well in terms of international public opinion, and Palestinians were often seen as the weaker side internationally.
Then there was a shift. The Palestinian leadership began adopting international terminology, particularly the language of human rights and the conventions you mentioned.
Today, Palestinian public discourse increasingly uses that international vocabulary.
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
I wish that the actions always matched the words. If they did, we would be in a very good place.
Udi Goren:
And the problem on the Israeli side – correct me if I'm wrong – is that we seem to be moving in the opposite direction. The Israeli public increasingly rejects international institutions and the language of international law. People say: “We don't care about the European do-gooders. We'll defend our country ourselves. We don't care about the ICC or the ICJ, or what they have to say. We're not part of that world.”
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
That is an important point. To bring about change, we need to understand where these values came from, how they developed and how they became institutionalised.
The idea of humanity, of course, is shared by many ancient civilisations. But we need to understand how values became institutions, laws and binding legal processes – first between states, then through organisations, and eventually at the level of individuals.
We also need to understand the global shift in consciousness during the 1990s and 2000s, and the adoption of human rights terminology.
This is a much broader discussion, and we could devote an entire podcast to the changes in Israeli society over the past 30 years, from the Second Intifada and the assassination of Rabin to the present day.
But our work at October 7 Justice Without Borders, representing 480 direct victims who have given us power of attorney, is ultimately also about the wider Israeli public. It is about all of us, and everyone who believes in democracy, in the values on which democracy is based, and in the resilience of democratic institutions.
Our work says something very simple: we are not inventing the law or reinventing the wheel. We are applying the values already enshrined in binding law.
The principle is that if you murder, you cannot simply get away with it. If you commit murder, you must be held accountable. And if you commit crimes systematically, on a widespread and organised basis, everyone within the structure who bears direct criminal responsibility must face justice through fair legal proceedings.
From Nuremberg to the present day, these principles have been applied in the former Yugoslavia, Rwanda, Sierra Leone and, more recently, Ukraine.
Our work is also part of a broader effort addressing crimes committed before October 7: ISIS crimes in Syria; crimes against the Uyghurs in China; crimes against the Rohingya in Myanmar; the Armenian genocide under the Ottoman Empire; and atrocities taking place today in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Eritrea, Sudan and elsewhere.
We are applying the same principles. We want the same standards of justice. We are working in the name of global justice.
This has been my world for more than 20 years, and I am now bringing it home through binding legal processes that can recognise victims, establish the truth and secure accountability.
Criminal proceedings set a very high evidentiary standard. They can also lay the foundations for civil claims against those who bear responsibility. We are pursuing different avenues, including against entities and other actors. That does not mean that we are automatically describing all of them as terrorist organisations; rather, we are examining their responsibility.
Udi Goren:
Can you give us an example?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
The judgments themselves can become part of the historical record, just as the Nuremberg judgments did. We want the legal proceedings concerning October 7 to be recorded internationally, not only in Israel.
That way, anyone who denies these atrocities will have to contend not only with Israeli courts – which are already under attack – but with courts around the world.
There is a great deal of confusion about which institutions are being attacked and by whom. The same blurring is happening both inside Israel and internationally. It is part of the wider disorder.
The law can help establish order in the positive sense: clarifying what is right and what is wrong. Legal recognition can also shape public narratives and educate future generations about those distinctions.
35:59 | Representing victims while navigating international proceedings against Israel
Udi Goren:
I want to ask a difficult question. Not necessarily difficult in terms of the law, but conceptually.
How do you deal with trying to engage with international law on the one hand, while challenging some of its decisions on the other?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
What do you mean?
Udi Goren:
We are pursuing proceedings at the ICC against Hamas figures, and I hope those responsible will face the full consequences. There are 480 families whose interests you represent, and many more victims. In Israel, around 85,000 people have been recognised by the National Insurance Institute as direct victims of the attacks. That's an enormous number.
But at the same time, there are proceedings at the ICJ against Israel, alleging genocide. And the ICC has also issued arrest warrants against Israel's Prime Minister and Yoav Gallant.
How do we reconcile all of this? We approach the international courts and say that decisions should be made according to the law and then implemented to achieve justice. But when a decision goes against us, the State of Israel says it does not recognise it or will not comply.
How does that affect your work and your ability to secure justice for the families?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
That's a very legitimate question, and it is part of the reality in which we conduct our legal work.
For us, the distinction is actually quite straightforward. We can do something that a sovereign state cannot do. When a state presents a position, it represents its own position and all the interests associated with it.
I am an independent, apolitical lawyer. I act on the basis of universal principles, and I represent victims.
The question of what people think about me is something that anyone can ask themselves. People will always have opinions about what we do. But the facts are the facts: I represent 480 victims, and each of them may represent several additional family members. In practice, we are talking about thousands of people.
We are acting to protect their rights: the right to truth, to justice, to reparations and to guarantees of non-repetition – in other words, to ensure that these things never happen again.
If someone wants to turn that into a political argument, they should look those victims in the eye and explain why they should not receive justice.
Udi Goren:
So you're saying that whether Benjamin Netanyahu or Yoav Gallant are being prosecuted is not your concern?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
That's not exactly what I mean. Your question is broader: does the Israeli government's refusal to comply with ICC decisions affect your work on behalf of the families?
We work with different mechanisms, both judicial and non-judicial. For example, we engage with UN human rights mechanisms in New York and Geneva. These are not necessarily judicial decisions; they may involve recognition or other forms of action.
All these bodies have independent mandates. They are supposed to be independent and impartial. If someone holding such a mandate is not independent, or is failing to fulfil it properly, we will call that out too – according to the mandate.
We work with independent institutions. We do not control what they decide to do.
And the fact is that our absence would not prevent those institutions from taking action against Israel or against Gaza. That is not what will stop them.
What needs to happen is what we are working towards: justice for the victims of October 7, and accountability for those who committed the crimes, ordered them or otherwise bear responsibility.
I believe we must be present in every relevant forum.
We are also working with the Federal Public Prosecutor in Germany, with the French National Anti-Terrorist Prosecutor's Office, and with a special unit in the United States in connection with the first trial of an individual who is already in custody. That trial is expected in January 2027.
We need to be wherever our presence is required. All of this is pro bono, because we genuinely believe in this work. I know that many people believe in it too, and that many are waiting for these proceedings to move forward, beyond the politics and all the noise, both inside and outside Israel.
Udi Goren:
Before we move on, I want to return to something you've emphasised: recognition, justice and the establishment of a historical narrative.
You argue that the legal process itself, and the legal findings it produces, can create a historical record that will shape the future.
But legal proceedings are also often about compensation. Is there a way to actually compel the people responsible to pay? After all, we are pursuing terrorists. And we see that even a head of state does not necessarily comply with an ICC decision.
Host:
Let's separate the different issues. The legal rules and practical circumstances are very different when dealing with a terrorist organisation that openly declares itself to be one and takes pride in its actions, compared with other individuals or officials.
Let's say we had brought a case against Mohammed Deif while he was still alive. What could actually have been done? Could he have been made to pay compensation to someone?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Yes, absolutely. But there are two separate questions here.
First, there are the legal proceedings themselves. Factually, these are separate proceedings based on different facts, different evidence and different legal questions. They are not the same case.
The second question concerns enforcement. How are arrest warrants actually enforced, and who is responsible for enforcing them?
States are responsible for enforcing arrest warrants. This can happen through international cooperation, including Interpol and border controls. An alert may be issued, and when someone crosses a border, the authorities may be required to arrest them.
It does not always happen. For example, Italy failed to arrest a Libyan official who was subject to an arrest warrant about a year and a half ago. The ICC then questioned Italy, as a member of the Court, about its failure to fulfil its obligations. Italy had to explain why it had not arrested him.
In another case, the person was arrested.
This is an ongoing process. Not every state always enforces every warrant, and not every individual is brought to justice immediately. But the legal obligation remains binding.
43:37 | Transitional justice: Moving from war towards peace
Udi Goren:
I want to return to the point you've placed the greatest emphasis on: achieving justice.
How is this part of the process of ending a conflict? How have countries that experienced conflicts just as violent and brutal as ours used this process to move towards the next stage?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
There are currently around 120 armed conflicts in the world. We obviously don't hear about all of them.
Throughout human history, there have been countless examples relevant to the concept of transitional justice. The term itself became more widely discussed in the 1990s, but the underlying recognition goes back to Nuremberg and even earlier.
By 1943, there was already recognition that military force alone was not enough to move from war to peace or stability. Diplomatic power is sometimes sufficient, but not always.
After the Second World War, the international community had to work out how to rebuild the world so that it would be based on peace rather than war. That does not mean that wars have disappeared. But the question was how to create a more stable international system.
The answer involved building institutions. It involved recognising, for example, that democracies tend to fight fewer wars. It involved rebuilding Europe with American funding through the Marshall Plan.
It also involved introducing principles, values and education, rebuilding industry, and establishing mechanisms for justice and legal accountability.
Justice is not the only element of this process, but it has an important place within it.
After the Second World War, the Nazis were disarmed. There was no negotiation with the Nazi leadership while they remained in power. They were prosecuted, but not every Nazi was brought to trial.
The proceedings focused on senior figures, doctors, lawyers, industrialists and others who had played particularly significant roles.
It's important to remember this, because people sometimes overlook it: the overwhelming majority of Nazis were never prosecuted. Many went on to integrate into the institutions of the states that emerged after the war. Some people served as judges both before and after the war. The same happened in other contexts, including after apartheid.
But a smaller number were prosecuted in order to establish the truth and hold individuals personally accountable.
Udi Goren:
And that process was nevertheless significant for the transition to the next stage.
There's something important about the idea that justice must be pursued – “Justice, justice shall you pursue” – and that genuine justice should not be achieved through vengeance.
Instead, you step away from the bloodshed, however painful that may be, and try to examine the facts objectively. You look at what happened, almost with a sense of detachment, but with a great deal of humanity.
You take those facts and turn them into a legal process.
46:44 | The Eichmann trial and its impact on Israeli society
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
The Eichmann trial is a good example. Israeli society was not the same before and after the trial of Adolf Eichmann.
Udi Goren:
Tell us what happened. What did it achieve?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
In the 1960s, Adolf Eichmann was brought to trial. The Mossad could potentially have killed him in Argentina with a single bullet. It could have been done without bringing him to trial.
But who needed this trial? David Ben-Gurion did. He was a visionary. He told the Mossad not to kill Eichmann, but to bring him to Jerusalem and conduct a fair trial.
Eichmann was eventually executed, although I don't think that execution itself was necessarily a good thing. But what did the trial achieve?
It gave something to Israeli society that is difficult to measure. People have devoted their entire lives to studying and writing about the significance of the Eichmann trial for Israeli society.
At the very least, it provided recognition of the truth. It created a legal process and gave victims a place to be heard, even if more survivors could perhaps have been called to testify and their role could have been more central.
It gave Israeli society a small window into the reality of the Holocaust and the scale of the genocide.
Until then, Israeli society had been very much focused on survival, on fighting and on rebuilding. There was a strong emphasis on the survivors who had come through the Holocaust and on the need to build a new society.
There was also a particular Israeli ideal of the sabra: the agricultural pioneer who builds something from the ground up.
The additional value of the Eichmann trial was that it helped change the way survivors were perceived. A survivor was not weak. A survivor was a hero. The emphasis was on surviving, rebuilding a family and starting again. That became an important Israeli value.
48:10 | Justice for Israelis and Palestinians: Can transitional justice build a bridge?
Udi Goren:
I want to ask a question that may be difficult.
In the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, both sides want justice. This is very different from the discussion of Nazi Germany, where one side was presented as absolute evil and the other as absolute good.
Here, the two sides have very different ideological understandings of what justice means.
How do we bridge that gap? If we want to move forward, we need to have the courage – which is extremely difficult – to look at the darker parts of the histories of both peoples.
Can we find a way to bridge the gap between what justice means to the average Israeli and what it means to the average Palestinian? Is there work we can do?
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Yes, absolutely. I think the key word you used is “bridge”. Transitional justice is a bridge.
You asked me for examples of other conflicts. South Africa is probably the best-known example. Argentina is another, and Colombia is a particularly interesting example today. We don't have time to explore them in depth now, but perhaps we can dedicate another episode to this.
These examples demonstrate that it is possible.
Colombia is particularly relevant because it shows how justice can be pursued within a society itself. We tend to think of the conflict as being between two separate entities – Israelis and Palestinians, or Arabs and Jews. But part of the complexity is that there are also divisions and conflicts within each society.
You asked whether politicisation makes my work more difficult today. When I meet certain people and say that I represent people who were harmed on October 7, they ask me: “What about the people who have been harmed in Gaza? Do you represent them?”
I tell them that I don't represent them, but they deserve justice. That is not complicated for me.
People constantly try to present these things as contradictory, but they are not.
Take someone who was harmed on October 7 – someone I represent, someone you may personally know. Put that person alongside a Palestinian who has been harmed.
The important distinction is between someone who has been harmed and someone who has committed a crime. They are not the same thing.
Some people say that everyone is a perpetrator. That is not true. There are people who were simply sleeping in their homes and died in a bombardment.
Whether a particular incident necessarily constitutes a war crime, genocide or another international crime is a separate legal question. I do not believe that everything Israel is doing in Gaza necessarily constitutes those crimes, although others may disagree with me.
What I do believe is that people have been harmed, and that everyone who has been harmed deserves justice. I don't think there is any real disagreement about that.
If we can accept this principle, we can begin to move forward.
Transitional justice, by definition, requires the courage to look at the pain of the past while facing forwards. We need both elements.
If we look at the past only to punish and kill in another way – not on the battlefield, but through legal proceedings – that is not transitional justice.
If we want to recognise the truth in order to move towards something new and better, as South Africa tried to do with a great deal of compassion and humanity, that is transitional justice.
I firmly believe that it is an extremely important tool for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It can happen here. In fact, it needs to happen here.
51:35 | Looking ahead: Lessons from Colombia and who must be part of the process
Udi Goren:
That's a good point on which to conclude.
At the end of every discussion, we want to ask ourselves what our takeaway is. And our clear takeaway is that there is a way forward. There is a methodology that has been tried around the world and has succeeded in some cases.
Some processes have worked better than others, but there have been long, violent and difficult conflicts that have eventually been resolved.
There is probably more than one way to address these conflicts, but transitional justice is certainly one path. It begins with recognising that what happened really happened, that the victims genuinely suffered, and that those responsible must be held accountable.
That is where everything begins. The aim is to look at the past without remaining trapped in it, and to turn towards the future.
Once that recognition has taken place, we can begin to think about what comes next.
I think this is the key, provided the process is honest, genuinely apolitical and undertaken with the willingness to confront painful realities.
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
And we should also recognise that even this process may involve a degree of injustice. Not every individual who has suffered will necessarily be satisfied with the outcome.
If we look at South Africa or Colombia, I am sure there are victims who are unhappy with the solutions that were ultimately reached. That is certainly possible.
But other peoples have gone through this process, even after conflicts that lasted hundreds or a thousand years. So a conflict that has lasted 100 years is not necessarily impossible to resolve.
I want to return to Colombia because it is an example of an intergenerational conflict. What is remarkable about the process there is how extensively they consulted victims and examined who the victims and parties to the conflict actually were.
Who needs to be involved in making peace within Palestinian society? Within Israeli society? And then between Palestinian and Israeli society?
What role should other countries play?
What about Jewish refugees from Arab countries? What about Palestinian refugees from 1948 and 1967?
Who are the parties to the conflict? Who bears responsibility? Who needs to be around the table?
In Colombia, they spoke with tens of thousands of people. It is an enormous country, and the process involved a great deal of consultation.
Udi Goren:
You're giving away the next episode! I think we've just decided that we're going to dedicate an entire episode to Colombia.
54:01 | A local story: Reconnecting across communities in Israel
Abraham Abu Ahmed:
Before Colombia, we end every episode with a story from everyday life here – a local story, this time from Herzliya.
This time, Hagar sent us a story. After she started listening to our podcast, she got back in touch with an old friend, Iman, whom she had studied with more than 20 years ago.
Iman is from Kafr Qara, and they had been close friends during their studies. Hagar suddenly called her and sent her our podcast to ask what she thought. As a result, they renewed their friendship.
Recently, Hagar went to visit her and met her daughters. Iman's eldest daughter lives in Toronto, not far from where Hagar's daughter lives. So both of them occasionally travel to Toronto to visit their children.
But something else happened during that visit. Hagar was able to bridge a gap in her understanding of what everyday life is like for an Arab woman in Israel.
We talk about this quite a lot on the podcast. It is one thing to discuss these issues in the abstract, but quite another to sit in a friend's home and hear about her experience.
Kafr Qara is a perfectly ordinary community, and in many respects a good place to live. But it also has serious crime problems, like other places in Israel. People are afraid to leave their homes in the evening.
Iman herself had to change jobs. She had been working with at-risk youth and was receiving threats.
Hearing about this first-hand, and seeing it for herself, really changed Hagar's understanding of what it means to be an Arab citizen in Israel in 2026.
I think that, in itself, is something important that the podcast has helped achieve.
Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman:
Absolutely. And I would encourage everyone to do exactly the same thing.
I would also like to add something about the way we speak about crime in Arab society.
The terminology matters, both legally and socially. It can be important to identify the problem specifically in order to find a solution.
But we need to understand that this is crime within Israeli society. It is crime in Israel, and it is a terrible problem. It is not something contained within separate borders, where everyone else can simply ignore it. It puts all of us at risk.
Abraham Abu Ahmed:
Exactly. We talk about this often, and we need to keep reminding ourselves that crime in Arab society is a problem for Israeli society as a whole.
56:19 | Closing remarks
Host:
We want to thank you very much for listening.
Please follow us on your favourite podcast app so that you receive a notification whenever a new episode is released.
You can find us on social media – it's very easy – and please send us your stories. We'd be very happy to share them here.
We would also like to thank our guest, Adv. Yael Vias Gvirsman.
I'm Udi Goren, here with Abraham Abu Ahmed. See you in the next episode!
